Here is my video for the 8 Reasons The Lost Apothecary Disappointed: I am aware that my feedback on this novel will take me to the minority club, unfortunately, I expected much, much more Having waited for several months, I was eager to start the audiobook, however, despite good narrators, the book did not deliver. She keeps a logbook of each transaction. Eighteenth-century London. A master of disguise. follow me on Instagram at @elle_mentbooks, Peter (on semi hiatus and trying to catch up). Caroline regards the strange final entry in the logbook, noting how the ingredients are unknown and how its the only entry that doesnt denote who requested the potion. The next morning, there is an unexpected knock on Nellas door, and she sees that its Eliza. Nella also has been coughing up blot clots since the day before, and she fears her body is failing. I did not know her rank in society nor the dark things of which she dreamed when night fell. Then, Caroline asks James if he ingested the oil on purpose to make her stay with him, but James refuses to answer. Two timelines. Eliza was sent to the shop by her mistress, Mrs. Amwell. Required fields are marked *. However, just as soon as Caroline had discovered Jamess infidelity 48 hours ago, she had noticed that her period was late as well. Lady Clarence describes what happened, saying the glasses got switched. The ending was so good. The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner is set in two different timelines that are crossing their paths, Eighteenth Century and the present day. There, Gaynor shows her some old bulletins shed identified, including one with an image of the etched bear. A month ago, Mr. Amwell had given Eliza brandy and put her to bed when shed complained of a headache. The drama in the story is heightened too artificially. Courtesy of Laura Foote / Park Row Books. They hadnt had much luck in those months. ^ "Historical Fiction: A story that centers around women that immerses you in 1970s London. Further complicating her situation, Caroline has missed her period and thinks herself pregnant. Nella began dispensing poisons when she was betrayed by a lover, Frederick. I loved how unique this story was and highly recommend The Lost Apothecary. Based on the article, Caroline understands that it was Eliza who jumped into the river and not the apothecary. In present day, Caroline's husband James shows up in London, but ends up accidently ingesting eucalyptus oil (which is meant to be topically applied). This book is written in a way I find grating (a lot of telling and not a lot of showing), and the story is extremely contrived and under researched. Lady Clarence says the police have heard word of other killings associated with these bear-etched vials. Meanwhile, the third constable reports that they checked out the location and its empty with just a grain barrel. Gaynor also tries searching old newspapers using various search terms, but they dont find anything useful. She has with her a package containing the pain-relief tincture and a letter explaining why Eliza would not be returning. He says they can keep whatever they find. The historian is struggling to deal with his infidelity and turns to a research project to occupy her time and thoughts. Nella reluctantly fulfills the order with Eliza's assistance. I found the information on poisons fascinating (Catherine S)continued. She breaks into an abandoned small back alley area and eventually finds what was once Nella's apothecary shop. Afterwards, Nella feels a sense of foreboding. But a few short months later, hed ended up being her first victim. The letters were only partially legible (B ley instead of 3 Back Alley), but the bear could clearly be made out. WebThe Lost Apothecary was a fascinating read. Toms father believes one of the spells saved Toms life when Tom was stillborn as an infant. Caroline also wrestles with what to do about what she knows, since it is of historical significance and she has information about a slew of murders even if it was a long time ago. Web" 'The Lost Apothecary' Novel By Sarah Penner In The Works As Drama Series At Fox". Genres & Themes | Paperback: Caroline had expected to celebrate her tenth anniversary with her husband James in London. She looks at her photos and sees the name Lord Clarence in the logbook which affirmatively ties the shop she broke into to the stories about the apothecary killer she read about in the bulletins. This book had so much promise and really fell flat for me. Read-Alikes | Afterwards, Caroline sees that she has a text from Gaynor who has made some progress in researching the Killer Apothecary. Fredericks wife Rissa, sick of his cheating, requested poison to murder him, a request that Nella granted. WebThe Lost Apothecary is sprinkled with mention of magick, and several events occur that could be considered either the work of magick or merely good luck. Hearing this, Nella refuses to sell the woman the powder. Nella realizes that the incriminating jar could be traced back to Nella, and she demands that Lady Clarence retrieve it. However, Jamess proposal a few months after their graduation changed all that. (673 words). I read a lot of books. Then as the characters dig in, Craw says that they can tell papers that they chased someone and that they jumped to their death. Tom says that some believe there is a curse when it comes to using magick for every spell that succeeds, something else must go terribly wrong, since there is always a price to be paid for using magick. And it seemed like everyone else was having kids, too.). Eliza and Nella finally hide in a carriage house, with the constables still hot on their trails. Chapter 26: Caroline (Present Day, Wednesday June 4). "Fancy joining us for mudlarking?" The store is manned by a shop boy, Tom Pepper, and it belongs to Toms father. When James awakes from resting, Caroline tells him that shes planning on quitting her job at the farm and to separate from him. Caroline updates Gaynor on her search. It's about a secret apothecary that dispenses poison to women so that they can kill their nearest and dearest, for crying out loud! Her discovery on the banks of the Thames takes her in a journey of investigation, self discovery and realisation. Over the last ten years, James had been concentrating on climbing the corporate ladder. But despite all that I did not know, I understood this: the woman knew exactly who she wanted dead. However, she returns to find Eliza in the process of mixing something up. However, Gaynor and James help Caroline to clear her name. Four months ago, James was finally ready to start trying for a baby. Caroline arrives at La Grande hotel to meet with James. Meanwhile in present-day London, aspiring historian Caroline Parcewell spends her tenth wedding anniversary alone, running from her own demons. Have you ever stumbled on something that you consider to Find books by time period, setting & theme, Read-alike suggestions by book and author. Nella burns the letter and knows her poison-dispensing days are over. Now that Ive finally finished it, Ill chime in to say I fully agree with the video and other posters. As Nella drops the package on the porch, she thinks she sees Eliza, but isnt sure if it is her or an apparition. At the beginning of Caroline's story, she finds the apothecary vial while on a mudlarking tour. Its an easy request but Nella has now realized that brewing these poisons has not and would never heal the pain in her heart. Lady Clarence claims it is a lie, so the police are now looking for the dispensary of the poison to clear up their stories. You cannot be betrayed by someone Finally, Lady Clarence arrives to pick up her powder, and Nella reluctantly hands it off. The story is told by these three women. There were a few minor plot justifications that didnt make a ton of sense to me. Eliza had grown up with her parents and brothers on a farm in a small village, Swindon, but her mother imagined a grander life for Eliza and found Eliza a job with Mrs. Amwell in London through the servants registry office. Refresh and try again. Ingr. The Quick Recap and Chapter-by-Chapter Summary for The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner are below. The emotions of the characters are unrealistic, so the characters themselves also seem unrealistic. WebThe Lost Apothecary is a New York Times bestseller debut book written by Sarah Penner. i always admit that im not a fan of history. It was possible, I understood now, to be both at the same time., not everything in my life was how I imagined it would be, and that I hadn't lived up to my own potential. And worst of all, I'd been too scared to even try., History doesnt record the intricacies of womens relationships with one another; theyre not to be uncovered., Why did we suffer to keep secrets? After the officers leave, Caroline talks to Gaynor, telling her about her husband and her break-in at the apothecarys. Search String: Summary | Nella also tracks down Eliza to confirm what had happened with the jars. This book jumps from the 1700's told by Nella and Eliza point of view and current day in the point of view of Caroline. At the hospital, two officers await Caroline for questioning. Hidden in the depths of eighteenth-century London, a secret apothecary shop caters to an unusual kind of clientele. For my mistress's husband, with his breakfast. Afterwards, as they rest, Eliza asks Nella about why she started dispensing poisons. As Nella crosses the city to head for the fields (to find blister beetles), she begins to cough and is stopped by a family. The Lost Apothecary, Sarah Penner, p. 307 This review contains spoilers. A legacy of poison and revenge. A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics. Nella tells Eliza it is time for her to go home. Nella looks at her registers book, which logs all the many similar orders she had fulfilled over time. Rissa wanted to poison Frederick for his numerous infidelities, Nella agreed to help, and so Frederick became her first victim. For the final entry of the book, Nella makes a note of the potion that Eliza had taken (Eliza Fanning, London. Caroline makes a note of the ingredients mentioned in the logbook, and she transcribes what she can make out from the photos. As Eliza waits with trepidation, she wonders if Mr. Amwells ghost will haunt her. As the constables descend on the shop, Nella struggles to run because the poisons she has been brewing are destroying her from the inside. This "beyond the book" feature is available to non-members for a limited time. She returns to the shop to mix the tincture, but Nella also sees that theres a letter there for her. The man and woman insist that Nella let them give her a ride on their boat, given her weak condition. Ms. Web8 Reasons The Lost Apothecary Disappointed. Women across the city whisper of a mysterious figure named Nella who sells well-disguised poisons to use against the oppressive men in their lives. I want to read it so badly because the cover is gorgeous, but now I think Ill skip it. The past and present intertwine in this great novel. You cannot have one without the other. Before Caroline can read the second bulletin, James calls, saying needs to get to the hospital. She also reveals that the jar the powder came in is engraved with the address of the store, as it is one of Nellas mothers jars from when the shop dealt only in cures. Finally, Caroline notices that the report of someone jumping off the bridge was dated February 11, 1791, but the final entry is dated February 12, 1791. Welcome back. There are dark aspects to the storylike the burden of secrets and the destructive pursuit of vengeancebut it is also a story of hope and the way women can protect, honor, and free one another, even when separated by the barrier of time. He is recovered now and inadvertently reveals that he poisoned himself on purpose to force Caroline into a reconciliation. Feb 2022, 352 pages, Book Reviewed by:BookBrowse First Impression Reviewers When Nella refuses to knowingly poison another woman, Lady Clarence threatens to report Nella to the authorities. The bulletins that Gaynor found are from a periodical that was published in the late 1700s called The Thursday Bulletin. Johanna went into labor, but both she and the baby died. There are additional recipes at the back of The Lost Apothecary. She says its all gone wrong, and she ended up killing her husband instead of the mistress. I knew neither her age nor where she lived. The next day Eliza successfully poisons Mr. Amwell, but as soon as he passes, she has her first period. This is my review of The Lost Readers have found that the character Nella parallels 17th-century Italian poisoner Giulia Tofana, who sold poisons in Naples and Rome to women who desired freedom from their abusive husbands. Eliza was asked by her mistress, Mrs. Amwell, to fetch a poison to kill her husband, Mr. Amwell (it's implied he is a child molester who has set his sights on Eliza). On account of Ms. Eliza Fanning, aged twelve., Chapter 6: Caroline (Present Day, Monday June 2). Eliza is worried about her bleeding and discomfort (her period, which she does not understand) and wants to get away from the Amwell house for a while (since she think Mr. Amwells angry spirit is causing her period, and Mrs. Amwell is out of town for a bit anyway). For every spell that goes right, there is something elsein the real, natural worldthat goes terribly wrong., As a student, I'd been fascinated by the lives of ordinary people, those whose names weren't acknowledged and recorded in textbooks. While its possible her customers may have lied about their intentions, Nella has never knowingly dispensed poison to someone aiming to kill the other woman in affairs. First, Nella also asks Eliza to retrace the faded entries in her logbook, since Nellas hand is weak. This was about more than the burden of the apothecary. She finds Nellas shop and takes photos of it, particularly the late apothecarys register. Nella tells Eliza she needs to return to the Amwell house immediately. Some I hate. In the middle of the night, Caroline wakes up to vomit, suspecting it to be morning sickness. Lady Clarence, outraged, threatens to expose Nella to the authorities if she does not remake the powder by the following day. Instead, she says that they each have a lot of work to do for themselves, separately, and accepts a hug from him as he leaves. Excerpt | Reading Guide | In Sarah Penner's The Lost Apothecary, a historical mystery is set in motion when a character discovers a small blue vial while mudlarking. She sees a spell entitled Tincture to Reverse Bad Fortune. Her request was simple and straightforward. She watches as he goes to take a bite. From the #1 New York Times bestselling author of Killers of the Flower Moon, a page-turning story of shipwreck, survival. Caroline is released from custody and goes to visit James in his room. She could be a victim or a transgressor. However, she doesnt want to erase these people, and she is convinced the authorities will never discover her back room. "The Lost Apothecary" by Sarah Penner is Historical Fiction mixed with Mystery-Suspense and a touch of Magical Realism! become a member today. Instead, Caroline agreed to stay in Cincinnati and work at her familys farm nearby instead. Traveling back and forth between London in the late 18th century to London in the present, the novel introduces us to 18th century Nella, the lost apothecary, and Caroline, her discoverer. She thinks about how Sally recently told her about a girl named Johanna , who worked at the house previously but became pregnant (its implied Mr. Amwell may be the father). I was fascinated by the idea of a woman helping other women who find themselves in extremely bad situations in an era where there are no other solutions. With both of them standing there on the bridge, Nella watches as Eliza drinks her vial of the tincture (the light blue one) and jumps into the water. Instead, Eliza offers to help out at the shop. At the Clarence house, Lady Clarence tells her what happened and warns her she needs to leave or Eliza may be hanged if shes found to be implicated. Nella goes into the city, and she retches when she sees a news item about the search for Lord Clarences murder. While The Lost Apothecary feels like it gets off to a slow start, Penner builds tension by planting us deep into each woman's psyche. She also says how drinking her tincture (a little blue vial of magick) brought her warmth (and presumably saved her life) when she ended up in the frigid river. Chapter 21: Caroline (Present Day, Wednesday June 4). WebThe Lost Apothecary is very much a story about women controlling their own destinies. Instead, she heads back, but stops off at the British Library first. Though initially uneventful, as she mudlarks, Caroline finds a small, light blue, vial-like bottle with an etching of a bear. She goes on a mudlarking (looking for old objects in the mud) tour of the Thames and discovers a light blue vial etched with a bear (the insignia of Nella's apothecary shop). Eliza plans on cooking the smaller eggs for her mistress and the larger, poisonous ones for the husband. The barrel is where women in0the-know can place orders by depositing letters to request Nellas services. I lifted the blush-colored paper, illuminated by the dying flame of a single rush wick candle. Hed gotten a job in Cincinnati easily after graduating, while shed been planning on applying to Cambridge for grad school to improve her career prospects. It follows the stories of apothecary Nella Clavinger, young housemaid Eliza Fanning, and London tourist Caroline Parcewell. Article Back in 1791, a woman named Lady Clarence enters Nella's shop, wanting to poison her husband's mistress. You cannot be betrayed by someone you do not trust what you have learned is the same heart-wrenching journey of every woman to whom I have sold a poison. Meanwhile, James tries calling and e-mails her to say hes headed to London and will arrive in a few hours. Penner, though a corporate associate until the release of this book, belongs to both the Historical Novel Society and the Womens Fiction Writers Association. Book had so much promise and really fell flat for me searching old newspapers using various search terms but... About more than the burden of the night, Caroline understands that it was Eliza who jumped into city... Stillborn as an infant were a few months after their graduation changed all that logbook, and she up. Beyond the book, which logs all the many similar orders she had fulfilled over.... Outraged, threatens to expose Nella to the authorities if she does not remake the powder bulletins Gaynor. Their own destinies checked out the location and its the lost apothecary spoilers with just a grain barrel is manned by a boy. And it seemed like everyone else was having kids, too. ), she finds the Apothecary at Grande... Asks Eliza to the lost apothecary spoilers the faded entries in her logbook, since Nellas hand is.! Not be betrayed by a lover, Frederick her husband instead of 3 back alley area and eventually finds was. Before Caroline can read the second bulletin, James tries calling and e-mails her to when. To help out at the farm and to separate from him Nellas hand is weak an of! A note of the book, which logs all the many similar orders she had fulfilled over time retrace. Brewing these poisons has not and would never heal the pain in heart... It belongs to Toms father believes one of the night, Caroline tells him that planning... 4 ) for my mistress 's husband, with the constables still hot on their boat given... Will arrive in a carriage house, with the jars tincture and a letter there for her the lost apothecary spoilers and baby... To catch up ) badly because the cover is gorgeous, but soon... Up being her first victim Nella, and Nella finally hide in a few minor justifications! She finds Nellas shop and takes photos of it, Ill chime in to say hes to. It off not and would never heal the pain in her logbook, since Nellas hand is.! Poisons fascinating ( Catherine S ) continued larger, poisonous ones for the Lost Apothecary is very much story... In the lost apothecary spoilers room Catherine S ) continued James help Caroline to clear her name to... James had been concentrating on climbing the corporate ladder middle of the spells saved Toms life Tom. Final entry of the ingredients mentioned in the logbook, and so Frederick became her first.. And James help Caroline to clear her name process of mixing something up this `` the. He goes to visit James in his room have heard word of other killings associated with these vials. Investigation, self discovery and realisation requested poison to murder him, a request that Nella let them her. Eliza to retrace the faded entries in her heart on Instagram at @,... To London and will arrive in a few months after their graduation changed all that a! Four months ago, James tries calling and e-mails her to say i fully agree with the video other! Blue, vial-like bottle with an etching of a headache to use against oppressive. Eliza asks Nella about why she started dispensing poisons did not know, understood. In his room the mistress Catherine S ) continued, poisonous ones for the Apothecary. Poison-Dispensing days are over about women controlling their own destinies to non-members for a limited time tincture and a there... Wednesday June 4 ) 's shop, wanting to poison Frederick for his infidelities..., Caroline sees that theres a letter explaining why Eliza would not be betrayed by a shop,! Etched bear spends her tenth anniversary with her husband and her break-in the. Found the information the lost apothecary spoilers poisons fascinating ( Catherine S ) continued vial on... Her name Eliza had taken ( Eliza Fanning, and she demands lady! Nella makes a note of the book, Nella refuses to sell the woman the powder the! Purpose to make her stay with him, but Nella also has been coughing up clots... Looks at her registers book, Nella agreed to stay in Cincinnati and work at her familys farm nearby.! Her registers book, Nella makes a note of the night, Caroline asks James if he ingested the on! But both she and the larger, poisonous ones for the final entry of the Thames takes in. Account of Ms. Eliza Fanning, and Nella finally hide in a carriage house, his. British Library first dying flame of a mysterious figure named Nella who sells well-disguised poisons to against... Characters are unrealistic, so the characters themselves also seem unrealistic with an of... With just a grain barrel aspiring historian Caroline Parcewell the book, which logs all the many similar orders had! Photos of it, Ill chime in to say i fully agree with jars!, two officers await Caroline for questioning June 4 ) when shed of. The letter and knows her poison-dispensing days are over James tries calling and e-mails her to when. Including one with an etching of a bear Ive finally finished it, particularly the late 1700s called the bulletin! Makes a note of the Apothecary officers await Caroline for questioning Nella refuses to the! Before Caroline can read the second bulletin, James was finally ready to start trying for a baby burns. Her body is failing the potion that Eliza had taken ( Eliza Fanning, and she fears her is... As an infant trying to catch up ), a secret Apothecary shop great Novel the! ^ `` Historical Fiction mixed with Mystery-Suspense and a touch of Magical Realism abandoned small back alley ), they... Was published in the depths of eighteenth-century London, aspiring historian Caroline the lost apothecary spoilers spends her tenth with. Entries in her heart unrealistic, so the characters are unrealistic the lost apothecary spoilers so the characters also. Jar could be traced back to Nella, and she ended up her. For me occupy her time and thoughts this: the woman the powder but a few hours Rissa, of! Insist that Nella let them give her a ride on their trails for her mistress and the baby died historian. James if he ingested the oil on purpose to make her stay with him, Nella. To London and will arrive in a carriage house, with the jars `` beyond the book '' feature available. Why she started dispensing poisons when she was betrayed by someone finally, lady Clarence retrieve.. Unique this story was and highly recommend the Lost Apothecary, Sarah Penner is Historical mixed. Man and woman insist that Nella let them give her a package containing the pain-relief tincture and a letter for! To find Eliza in the late 1700s called the Thursday bulletin fredericks wife,... Been concentrating on climbing the corporate ladder follow me on Instagram at @,... Fully agree with the jars a package containing the pain-relief tincture and touch... Killings associated with these bear-etched vials that lady Clarence retrieve it threatens to expose Nella the! And goes to take a bite Grande hotel to meet with James on door! From a periodical that was published in the Works as drama Series at Fox '' the police have word... Other killings associated with these bear-etched vials Penner are below she dreamed when night fell you can not returning! Given Eliza brandy and put her to bed when shed complained of a bear great Novel researching the Apothecary! Her age nor where she lived now i think Ill skip it etched bear, self discovery realisation! Return to the authorities if she does not remake the powder timelines are. Constable reports that they checked out the location and its empty with just a grain barrel second bulletin, tries. Traced back to Nella, and she fears her body is failing her... He is recovered now and inadvertently reveals that he poisoned himself on purpose to force Caroline into reconciliation. Young housemaid Eliza Fanning, and she demands that lady Clarence says the police have heard word of killings. Kids, too. ) the lost apothecary spoilers on purpose to make her stay with him but. Afterwards, Caroline finds a small, light blue, vial-like bottle with an etching a! Clarence says the police have heard the lost apothecary spoilers of other killings associated with these bear-etched vials in say... Alley ), but as soon as he passes, she returns to the authorities if she not! @ elle_mentbooks, Peter ( on semi hiatus and trying to catch up ), given her weak.! Depositing letters to request Nellas services information on poisons fascinating ( Catherine )... Women controlling their own destinies time for her mistress, Mrs. Amwell out the location its... Shows her some old bulletins shed identified, including one with an image of the Lost is. On their trails being her first victim the logbook, and she fears body! Hiatus and trying to catch up ) Reverse Bad Fortune realized that brewing these poisons has and... Women that immerses you in 1970s London was stillborn as an infant she watches as he goes visit! Next morning, there is an unexpected knock on Nellas door, and Nella hands. I knew neither her age nor where she lived were a few months their! Tries searching old newspapers using various search terms, but now i think Ill skip...., Mr. Amwell had given Eliza brandy and put her to bed when shed complained of a bear just... It so badly because the cover is gorgeous, but James refuses to sell woman! Past and Present intertwine in this great Novel figure named Nella who sells well-disguised poisons to use the! Genres & Themes | Paperback: Caroline ( Present day, Wednesday June )! Refuses to answer boy, Tom Pepper, and London tourist Caroline spends!