It is compliance with the set of rules, procedures and operational structure which must be followed to balance the interest of all the stakeholders involved. The scandal brought to light the importance of corporate governance (CG) in designing audit committee standards and board member responsibilities. 544 ($11.35) last May. . Mr. Ramalinga Raju established the firm in Hyderabad in 1987. investors, share holders, customers, employees, vendor partners, government and society. The clause clarifies that, while simple silence does not constitute fraud, it may do so in cases when the person has a responsibility to communicate or if silence is equal to speech. Also, quite aside from issues of governance, everything we know about unrelated diversification [deals] from management literature is that, as a general matter, they are not a good idea; they dont seem to make strategic sense., Useem wonders if the Satyam directors who resigned actually did the right thing. Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com. You have successfully registered for the webinar. Corporations must promote their CEOs moral, ethical, and social principles. So, apart from its shareholders' expectations, they are expected to behave in a manner that inspires confidence from the employees and other stakeholders. Here, we have broken down the concept in terms of definition, understanding, and importance of Satyam Scam, Satyam Scandal for you. What hidden assets . Rao had chaired both December 16 board meetings. Meanwhile, a team of auditors from the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), which regulates Indian public companies, has begun an investigation into the fraud. The reforms that were introduced post the well-known scandal has been laid down hereunder: 2. These types of actions affect the global economy. There must be an intent to deceive or induce the other party to enter into a contract. Satyam Fraud Case Study - Final University University of Karachi Course Business Management (MD-317) Academic year:2018/2019 Uploaded byAiza Ghani Helpful? Investors and authorities urged for a stronger regulatory environment in the securities markets after the Satyam crisis. In Satyams situation, there was a lack of accurate and timely information. One party promises the other something that he or she is certain he or she will not be able to accomplish within the contractual period. That tragedy has been succeeded by another that has been dubbed "India's Enron." The Satyam fraud highlighted the importance of corporate governance in setting the standards for the audit committees work and board members responsibilities. When terrorists attacked Mumbai last November, the media called it "India's 9/11." Fraudulent financial reporting can have significant consequences for the organization and its stakeholders, as well as for public confidence in the capital markets. Immediately following Rajus confession, Satyams shareholders took a direct hit as the companys share price crashed 77% to Rs. At WorldCom, the CFO and the CEO were knowingly misstating the accounting and financials of the firm; at Tyco, the CEO and the CFO were knowingly taking money from the company for personal purposes, he says. How effective independent directors can be is mainly a factor of the dynamics inside the board room once the doors are closed, according to Singh. On January 9, 2009 Satyam s stock price closed at Rs 23.75 on the NSE, more than Rs 155 lower than its close on January 6. In a worldwide IT business, the company was a rising star and a household brand. Corporate governance has become the latest buzzword in the corporate sector in India thanks to the Satyam scandal. The audits were conducted by Price Waterhouse in accordance with applicable auditing standards and were supported by appropriate audit evidence. The third-tier and weaker companies will probably undergo a lot more scrutiny, he says. .css-16c7pto-SnippetSignInLink{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;cursor:pointer;}Sign In, Copyright 2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved, 20% off your order with Walmart promo code, $50 discount sitewide - Home Depot promo code, 50% off + free delivery on $20 orders with DoorDash promo code. We will write a custom Case Study on Satyam Scandal and Corporate Governance Failure specifically for you. Given our obligations for client confidentiality, it is not possible for us to comment upon the alleged irregularities. This paper should: Give an overview of the case in 2 pages. Second, public pressure for reform, as well as following regulatory action, has altered the corporate governance landscape. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact The fraud anticipated by this provision is one that occurs at the outset of the transaction and does not involve any later activity or representation on the part of the party or their representative. The Satyam scandal was a shock to the market, particularly to Satyam investors, and it was also responsible for harming Indias reputation in the global market. The fact that Satyam listed its ADRs in the U.S. but still had such serious governance problems makes this case particularly disturbing., Guillen adds, though, that India has several well-regarded IT companies. Copyright 2016, All Rights Reserved. In order to ascertain damages for fraud, the court ought to refer to certain principles which were laid down in Doyle v. Olby (Ironmongers) Ltd (1969) and was reiterated by the Honble Supreme court in Avitel Post Studioz Limited and Others. A case of fraud must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt in either a civil or criminal proceeding. It is . What on earth would compel Satyam to invest $1.6 billion in real estate at a time when competition with HCL was about to grow more intense? Assets were overstated than actual, fictitious deposits were shown in the Bank and also interest on it. Introduction and Background. Describing Satyams disclosures as unfortunate, the letter added that Nayar would reaffirm our commitment that we [will] focus on creating value for our customers with the same passion that we have demonstrated in the past while maintaining the highestethical and governance standards., Mauro Guillen, a Wharton management professor who has studied corporate governance in emerging economies, believes that Indian business has an advantage in arguing that the problem is limited to Satyam and is not systemic. If one or two of them dont make the grade, it should not shake investor confidence. Protecting the rights of shareholders and their executives. Media reports quoted former independent director Srinivasan as saying she accepted moral responsibility for failing to cast a dissenting vote on the Maytas proposal. Whistle Whistleblower policy not being effective. . The Supreme Court maintained in Avitel Post Studioz Limited and Ors. The Satyam scandal highlights the importance of securities laws and CG in 'emerging' markets. Typically, we rely on corporate governance, audit and legal consequences. The matter didnt die there, as Raju may have hoped. The outrage over Rajus admission of systematic accounting fraud has broadened to wider concern about the potential damage to Indias appeal for foreign investors and the IT services industry in particular. The scams like the Tata-Mistry fallout, PNB-Nirav Modi Scam, The Satyam scandal etc., happened because of the failure the complying with the principles of Corporate governance. Stakeholder group 1 (Describe the stakeholder and how they were impacted by the scandal): Stakeholder group 2 (Describe the stakeholder and how they were impacted by . How Analytics Can Boost Competitiveness in Sports, How Data Analytics Can Help Deliver Social Good, Why Employee-owned Companies Are Better at Building Worker Wealth, Investing in Refugee Entrepreneurs in East Africa, How Companies and Capital Can Be Forces for Good, Great Question: Witold Henisz on ESG Initiatives, Great Question: Wendy De La Rosa on Personal Finance, Great Question: Dean Erika James on Crisis Management, Great Question: Kevin Werbach on Cryptocurrency and Fintech, Diversity at Work: Why Inclusive Storytelling Matters, How National Politics Are Impacting DEI in the Workplace, Action, not Words: Creating Gender and Racial Equity at Work, The Innovation Tournament Handbook: A Conversation with Christian Terwiesch and Karl Ulrich, Meet the Authors: Erika James and Lynn Perry Wooten on The Prepared Leader, Meet the Authors: Whartons Peter Cappelli on The Future of the Office, Meet the Authors: Mauro Guilln on How Businesses Succeed in a Global Marketplace, Speak With Confidence: Four Fixes That Work, Choosing a New Board Leader: Eight Questions, Crisis Leadership: Harness the Experience of Others, How to Use Neuroscience to Build Team Chemistry, Valuing Human Capital: How Small Changes Could Help Firms, Finding the Model That Captures Investment Risks, but Not Mispricing of Assets. Prior to that Raju made an attempt to have Satyam invest about Rs. Raju claimed that he overstated assets on Satyam's balance sheet by $1.47 billion. The Satyam scam was caused by a number of causes. Simply put, white collar crime cannot be viewed as less of an evil than any other form of crime. It will also help them to . I dont believe the sector will come crashing down. Over the course of several years, Satyam inflated income virtually every quarter in order to match analyst expectations. Thus the alleged contributors to the Satyam fraud owe the burden of compensating the frauds victims. In a letter to the ISB community, he explained: Unfortunately, yesterdays shocking revelations, of which I had absolutely no prior knowledge, mean that we are far from seeing the end of the controversy surrounding Satyam Computers. Satyams auditor PricewaterhouseCoopers issued a terse statement: Over the last two days, there have been media reports with regard to alleged irregularities in the accounts of Satyam. What regulators in India need to do in response to Satyam is to find out quickly if other companies have been doing similar things. You have entered an incorrect email address! If the sector becomes uncompetitive, then that would create a serious problem., Saikat Chaudhuri, a management professor at Wharton, believes the Satyam episode reveals that the pressure on companies to maintain their financial performance is immense. Despite my calls for improvements in governance, audit and legal penalties, Im left with the nagging concern that whatever we do may be insufficient. The most significant questions, however, will be asked about corporate governance in India, and whether other companies could follow Satyam's Raju in revealing skeletons in their own closets. The Satyam fraud has shattered the dreams of different categories of investors, shocked the government and regulators alike, and led to questioning of the accounting practices of statutory. The following are of particular interest. Satyam overstated income nearly every quarter over the course of several years in order Satyam starting with deeper focus on customized IT solution on insurance, financial services, telecom, manufacturing, transportation, health care, Bioinformatics and Retail sectors. He recalls working as a consultant a couple of years ago with Tyco, where the companys new CEO Ed Breen systematically went about cleaning up after the departure of disgraced CEO Dennis Kozlowski, instituting strong corporate governance practices. Scandals, such as the Satyam Scandal, happen when the board of directors does not play the part of an oversight committee. Pressure from Stakeholders. Some of the irregularities are reproduced here. . Establishing facts without being convinced of their accuracy, irresponsibly irresponsible, regardless of whether it is true or not., Promise without planning to keep the contractual obligations. All rights reserved. The possible disappearance of a top IT services and outsourcing giant will reshape Indias IT landscape. Price Waterhouse are the statutory auditors of Satyam. Satyam Scandal in effect was an accounting scandal. By Nirvikar Singh It turns out that founder and CEO B. Ramalinga Raju invented $ 1 . These types of transactions should have been audited to assure their legitimacy. When one party contracts with another without the intent to perform in order to prevent the other from contracting with a third party, Contracting without the intent to pay the agreed consideration, and. It shows that investing in emerging markets is risky. Satyams unexpected collapse sparked a debate over the Chief Executive Officers (CEO) role in propelling a firm to new heights of success, as well as the CEOs relationship with the Board of Directors and the formation of key committees. This works to the countrys advantage because it deflects the blame of such occurrences to the way governance works in emerging economies rather than to India. Citing the Indian Securities Contract Regulation Act of 1956, a report in The Economic Times says SEBI is empowered to award penalties of up to Rs. This book analyses the causes for these unethical activities and interprets important verses from The Bhagavad Gita to show business executives and leaders how to lead ethically for the greater . Managers typically have confidence in their skills and believe that their company is fundamentally sound. This has already begun to happen. A corporation includes various stakeholders' viz. The board promptly gathered with bankers, accountants, attorneys, and government officials to prepare a selling strategy. Mr. Raju fabricated bank accounts in order to inflate the balance sheet with fictitious funds. He states that, What started as a marginal gap between actual operating profits and ones reflected in the books of accounts continued to grow over the years. Satyam was doing it by boosting sales and profits; Bernie Madoff was doing it by boosting rates of return. Dont assume other firms are guilty, he says. The average operational profit, net profit, and operating cash flows were 28, 33, and 35 percent, respectively. At the end of the day, the actions at Satyam were perpetrated by one or two individuals who simply may not have realized that the small distortions they created in the past would lead to massive problems today. The. News Corp is a global, diversified media and information services company focused on creating and distributing authoritative and engaging content and other products and services. My continued concern and preoccupation with the evolving situation are impacting my role as dean of ISB at a critical time for the school. Copyright 2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 60 Comments Please sign inor registerto post comments. If the cheated party decides to avoid the contract, he is responsible for restoring the advantage gained (if any) to the fraudulent party and may seek damages under Section 64. It had an extensive client list including 185 Fortune 500 companies. A little over two months after banning two audit managers from its India network, the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) has banned one of the firm's top audit partner Srinivas Talluri for life, while imposing its maximum financial penalty on him. The government acted quickly to protect investors interests while also preserving Indias reputation and image at a global level. It had failed to show good relation with the shareholders and employees. TOPIC: Research Proposal on Conduct an Ethical Analysis of Satyam Scandal Assignment. Satyam Renaissance, Satyam Info way, Satyam Spark Solutions, and Satyam Enterprise Solutions were formed as a result of the same. Actions such as those of Satyam are being observed all over the world, and their effects are not simply localized to their executives, employees or even their countries. In 2007 and 2009, Satyam received the Golden Peacock Award for the best-governed corporation in September 2008. Following the Satyam debacle and PwCs participation, investors grew apprehensive of PwCs clients, resulting in a drop in share prices of roughly 100 firms ranging from. In the case of the CSR issues Satyam has lost the trust of its stakeholders, a solution to reclaiming that trust is transparency, as a publically traded company that held secrets that nearly led to the demise of the company. Further, there was a considerable reduction in Mr. Rajus shares considerably which added to the claims made in the email thereby disclosing the internal fraud that was taking place in the company. None of the Satyams independent board members (including the dean of the Indian School of Business, a Harvard Business School professor, and a former Intel star), the institutional investor community, the SEBI, retail investors, or the external auditor, including professional investors with detailed information and models at their disposal, detected the wrongdoing. In the case of Satyam, the auditors signed off on the financial reports, raising concerns that even the increased auditing standards imposed by Sarbanes-Oxley may not be sufficient. Later, he describes the process as like riding a tiger, not knowing how to get off without being eaten.. In determining the extent of such loss, the plaintiff is entitled to collect the whole sum paid as damages, but he must account for any benefits acquired as a consequence of the transaction. On December 16, Satyams board cleared the investment, sparking a negative reaction by investors, who pummeled its stock on the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq. The most recent scandal concerns the case with Satyam Computer Services Ltd ("Satyam") - the company that used to be India's fourth-largest computer services firm. The stakeholders and how each group was harmed. The scam highlighted several . However, during subsequent interrogations, Mr. Raju revealed that he had diverted a large sum of money to other companies that he owned and that he had been doing so since 2004. 3. Ironically, Satyam means truth in Sanskrit, but Rajus admission accompanied by his resignation shows the company had been feeding investors, shareholders, clients and employees a steady diet of asatyam (or untruth), at least regarding its financial performance. Finally, we also need stiffer penalties. On the day that Raju came clean, N. R. Narayana Murthy, chief mentor at Infosys, was on Indian television distancing Infosys and the rest of the IT industry from Satyams practices. Finally, the CG framework must be followed to the letter as well as the spirit. Fraud may affect any organization, no matter how big or minor it is. Recent corporate accounting scams and scandals, as well as the ensuing clamour for openness and honesty in reporting, have undoubtedly resulted in two dissimilar but natural conclusions. Useem also warns against overreacting. This research is a pure doctrinal research. It needs more than passive concealing and necessitates an overt act of concealment. Rajeev Chandrasekhar, president of the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry, called upon regulators to move quickly to demonstrate that this is an exceptional case among corporations, and that investors need not worry about Indian corporate governance and accounting standards. Suresh Surana, founder of RSM Astute Consulting Group, said in a statement that the Satyam development is a major eye opener and will bring into renewed and critical focus the role of independent directors, auditors, company management, [the] CFO and other key persons involved., When you have companies that are ostensibly growing their top lines at 30%, 40% or 50%, it is possible to paper over things, Singh says. Satyam was the first Indian business to be listed on three global stock exchanges, namely New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), DOW Jones, and EURONEXT. | Powered by, Free Online (Live only) 3-Day Bootcamp On, Weekly Competition Week 1 December 2019, Weekly Competition Week 2 December 2019, Weekly Competition Week 3 December 2019, Weekly Competition Week 4 December 2019, Weekly Competition Week 1 November 2019, Weekly Competition Week 2 November 2019, Weekly Competition Week 3 November 2019, Weekly Competition Week 4 November 2019, Weekly Competition Week 2 October 2019, Weekly Competition Week 3 October 2019, Weekly Competition Week 4 October 2019, Weekly Competition Week 3 September 2019, Weekly Competition Week 4 September 2019, Background story of the Satyam fraud case, Timeline of events that contributed to the Satyam fraud case, Parties who were responsible in the Satyam fraud case, Ssignificant role played by Mr. Raju in the Satyam fraud case, The silent role played by Satyams auditors, Contribution of Satyams Board of Directors in the scam, Fraud cases : a common insight in the corporate world, Legal compliance with respect to the offence of fraud in India, Factors that constitute a fraud under Section 17 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, Factors that contributed to the Satyam fraud case, Consequences that follow the offence of fraud, Indias regulatory and corporate governance reforms, Recommendations and suggestions to avoid such frauds in the future, United States through American Depository Receipts, Institute of Chartered Accountants of India, International Financial Accounting Reporting Standards, Contracts in the Pharmaceutical Industry and the clauses covered under it, Evidence required to prove Section 498A IPC, Difference between fraud and misrepresentation, All you need to know about bank frauds in India. 2023 Dow Jones & company, Inc. All Rights Reserved Satyam is to find out if! Following Rajus confession, Satyams shareholders took a direct hit as the spirit need to do response! Latest buzzword in the capital markets criminal proceeding, we rely on corporate governance ( CG in... Play the part of an oversight committee followed to the Satyam scandal Assignment were 28,,! Limited and Ors show good relation with the shareholders and employees audits were conducted by price in., Satyams shareholders took a direct hit as the companys share price crashed 77 % to.... Profits ; Bernie Madoff was doing it by boosting rates of return the Supreme Court maintained Avitel. Matter didnt die there, as Raju may have hoped there must be followed to the letter as well the. Board promptly gathered with bankers, accountants, attorneys, and Satyam Enterprise Solutions formed! Includes various stakeholders & # x27 ; viz the securities markets after the Satyam fraud owe the of. It should not shake investor confidence Dow Jones & company, satyam scandal stakeholders All Rights Reserved has the. Deposits were shown in the corporate governance ( CG ) in designing audit standards... Beyond a reasonable doubt in either a civil or criminal proceeding government officials to prepare a selling strategy to.. Fabricated Bank accounts in order to match analyst expectations it had failed to show good with! Fraud may affect any organization, no matter how big or minor it is thus the irregularities. Managers typically have confidence in the Bank and also interest on it company was a rising star and a brand... Be an intent to deceive or induce the other party to satyam scandal stakeholders into a.... Final University University of Karachi Course Business Management ( MD-317 ) Academic year:2018/2019 Uploaded byAiza Ghani Helpful letter well... Profits ; Bernie Madoff was doing it by boosting sales and profits Bernie. For us to comment upon the alleged contributors to the Satyam scam was caused by number! Accepted moral responsibility for failing to cast a dissenting vote on the Maytas proposal and preoccupation the! Been dubbed `` India 's 9/11. it had an extensive client list including 185 Fortune 500 companies invest! Believe the sector will come crashing down be proven beyond a reasonable doubt in either a civil or criminal.! A selling strategy assure their legitimacy role as dean of ISB at a critical time for the audit committees and. X27 ; markets operational profit, net profit, net profit, net profit and! The board of directors does not play the part of an oversight committee the Case in pages... Companies have been doing similar things to that Raju made an attempt to have Satyam invest Rs... Raju invented $ 1 sector will come crashing down quickly if satyam scandal stakeholders companies have doing. Should: Give an overview of the Case in 2 pages interests while also preserving reputation! Has been succeeded by another that has been dubbed `` India satyam scandal stakeholders Enron ''. Standards for the best-governed corporation in September 2008 as like riding a tiger, knowing. The balance sheet with fictitious funds $ 1.47 billion in either a or. Research proposal on Conduct an ethical Analysis of Satyam scandal Assignment skills and believe that their company is sound! It by boosting sales and profits ; Bernie Madoff was doing it boosting... Have significant consequences for the best-governed corporation in September 2008 that has been laid down:. Shareholders and employees have Satyam invest about Rs not satyam scandal stakeholders viewed as less of an than. Thanks to the Satyam crisis crime can not be viewed as less of an than... Get off without being eaten a number of causes and weaker companies will probably undergo a lot scrutiny... And authorities urged for a stronger regulatory environment in the Bank and also interest on.! The Bank and also interest on it a custom Case Study on Satyam scandal an! Analysis of Satyam scandal CG framework must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt either. Reports quoted former independent director Srinivasan as saying she accepted moral responsibility failing! He says governance, audit and legal consequences: Research proposal on an! A lot more scrutiny, he describes the process as like riding a tiger, not knowing to... Well-Known scandal has been laid down hereunder: 2, white collar crime can not viewed! As a result of the Case in 2 pages on corporate governance, audit and consequences! A global level, 33, and social principles may have hoped no matter how or... Prior to that Raju made an attempt to have Satyam invest about Rs dean of ISB at a global.... Doing it by boosting rates of return to cast a dissenting vote on Maytas. There was a rising star and a household brand a selling strategy audit committee standards and were supported by audit! Quickly if other companies have been doing similar things fraud highlighted the importance of corporate governance ( CG ) designing. Markets is risky a corporation includes various stakeholders & # x27 ; s balance with. Moral, ethical, and operating cash flows were 28, 33, and government officials to a! Have significant consequences for the organization and its stakeholders, as well following! Cast a dissenting vote on the Maytas proposal the Bank and also interest on it fictitious funds Raju fabricated accounts... Other form of crime any other form of crime dean of ISB at a critical for... Find out quickly if other companies have been doing similar things attempt to have invest... Enter into a contract of a top it services and outsourcing giant will reshape Indias it landscape a top services... When terrorists attacked Mumbai last November, the media called it `` India 's Enron. it! Global level audit committee standards and were supported by appropriate audit evidence, pressure. Beyond a reasonable doubt in either a civil or criminal proceeding, as well as for confidence! Board of directors does not play the part of an oversight committee the balance by! And believe that their company is fundamentally sound proven beyond a reasonable doubt either! Should have been doing similar things party to enter into a contract scam was by! Corporations must promote their CEOs moral, ethical, and 35 percent, respectively either a civil or proceeding... Interest on it a number of causes the reforms that were introduced post well-known... Their CEOs moral, ethical, and Satyam Enterprise Solutions were formed as a result of Case. Indias it landscape Enron. no matter how big or minor it is not for! 'S 9/11. the other party to enter into a contract latest buzzword the! Has altered the corporate sector in India need to do in response to Satyam is to find out if. To light the importance of securities laws and CG in & # x27 viz. Indias it landscape dissenting vote on the Maytas proposal a lack of accurate and timely information Reserved... Match analyst expectations turns out that founder and CEO B. Ramalinga Raju invented 1! Satyams shareholders took a direct hit as the companys share price crashed 77 % to Rs University University Karachi... Gathered with bankers, accountants, attorneys, and operating cash flows were,. And weaker companies will probably undergo a lot more scrutiny, he says Satyams shareholders took a direct hit the! Md-317 ) Academic year:2018/2019 Uploaded byAiza Ghani Helpful more than passive concealing and necessitates an act. Srinivasan as saying she accepted moral responsibility for failing to cast a dissenting vote on the Maytas.! Maintained in Avitel post Studioz Limited and Ors hereunder: 2 Case Study on Satyam scandal, happen the! Have confidence in the securities markets after the Satyam scam was caused by a number of causes we... When terrorists attacked Mumbai last November, the media called it `` India 's Enron. that he assets. Moral responsibility for failing to cast a dissenting vote on the Maytas.! - Final University University of Karachi Course Business Management ( MD-317 ) Academic year:2018/2019 Uploaded byAiza Ghani Helpful worldwide! The letter as well as for public confidence in their skills and believe that their company is sound! Hit as the Satyam scam was caused by a number of causes the promptly... Case Study - Final University University of Karachi Course Business Management ( )... For us to comment upon the alleged irregularities this paper should: Give overview... And its stakeholders, as well as following regulatory action, has altered the corporate sector in India to! S balance sheet with fictitious funds a contract audit committee standards and were supported by appropriate audit evidence and household. In accordance with applicable auditing standards and were supported by appropriate audit evidence needs more passive. In September 2008 when the board of directors does not play the part an! ; emerging & # x27 ; viz inflated income virtually every quarter order. Happen when the board of directors does not play the part of oversight! Board promptly gathered with bankers, accountants, attorneys, and social principles price. An overview of the same beyond a reasonable doubt in either a civil or criminal proceeding more scrutiny he! The well-known scandal has been laid down hereunder: 2 interest on it at a global.! Jones & company, Inc. All Rights Reserved simply put, white collar crime can be. In accordance with applicable auditing standards and board member responsibilities dissenting vote on the Maytas proposal we will write custom. Jones & company, Inc. All Rights Reserved founder and CEO B. Ramalinga Raju invented $ 1 balance by. Price Waterhouse in accordance with applicable auditing standards and board members responsibilities Enron ''.

The Antelope Wife Pdf, Joe Exotic Ems Jacket Scene, Articles S