So, if you are still curious then you may just have to try it for yourself and see. Kerrygold Butter Vs. Countryside Creamery Irish Butter: Which Is Better. Hihas anyone had any issues with this butter? Start shopping online now with Instacart to get your favorite products on-demand. Your email address will not be published. They wrote of the difference between the two, "I'm having a hard time putting it in to words, though. If not, well, we think you should be! We do not accept Manufacturers' Coupons. This blind tasting was incredibly challenging. We are not responsible for printing or typographical errors. One person did note, however, that the Country Crock version of the spread was ever so slightly softer, but noted nothing in terms of the taste. The Aldi Nerd easily gives Kerrygold higher marks, claiming the difference is undeniable, while Aldi Reviewer notes that, although it costs slightly less than what Kerrygold did from Aldi, and it looks and tastes similar, it simply isn't the same: "You can't just explain it, [Kerrygold] just tastes better," the reviewer notes. Calorie breakdown: 100% fat, 0% carbs, 0% protein. Kerrygold is sold in many parts of the world, including Europe, and it was first introduced into the United States in 1991. That little bit of extra fat provides a richer flavor and creamier texture. The extra butterfat makes it extremely creamy. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window). Vital Farms Pasture-Raised Butter is the butter brand to buy if your fridge is full of free-range and cage-free eggs. ), Does Aldi Accept EBT Online? Required fields are marked *. Countryside Creamery For product ingredients, availability, and concerns please contact the brand owner, Aldi directly: https://www.aldi.us/en/about-aldi/contact-us/ slide 1 of 1 REAL Dairy Products Butter Countryside Creamery Butter - Salted Countryside Creamery Butter - Unsalted Related Brands ALDI Bremer Fit & Active Friendly Farms Happy Farms For a budget-friendly butter that still tastes delicious, our Test Kitchen recommendsChallenge Butter. Protein. The color and style look suspiciously like the old-style Country Crock Spread tubs, which of course is probably the whole idea (although at the time of this post Country Crock had moved on to a more square design). Carbs. Although this 2% difference may not seem like a big deal on the surface, many people claim that this is the reason that Country Creamerys Irish butter falls short in taste compared to the perfect Irish butter produced by Kerrygold. Reviews + More). We reserve the right to limit quantities sold. Well, weve got you covered. I noticed it first in mashed potatoes (thought it was just me) then again this morning in my oatmeal and on my toast. The Aldi spread is a little less healthy than the Country Crock, with higher calories (60 vs. 50), saturated fat (2g vs. 1.5g), and sodium (110g vs. 100g) per 1-tablespoon serving. One way that the company can guarantee such low prices is by taking over the production of the products itself. Your welcome folks, I love spreading good health to like minded people. Irish butter is advertised as softer than American butter, and on that front the Countryside Creamery Irish butter doesnt disappoint. Its pretty easy to cut and use, and it spreads easier than stick butter, too, especially if you give it a couple of minutes to sit out of the refrigerator. 1 Tablespoon Countryside Creamery Unsalted Butter, room temperature 3 Tablespoon Peanut Delight No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter* 4 Tablespoons Baker's Corner Brown Sugar 1/2 teaspoon Stonemill Pure Vanilla Extract 1 egg yolk 3 Tablespoons Baker's Corner All Purpose Flour 1/8 teaspoon salt 1/8 teaspoon baking soda Granulated sugar, optional Find it in stores: Countryside Creamery Spreadable Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt, $2.29 for 15 ounces. European butter contains about 82 percent, while American contains just 80 which, combined with its higher water content, results in an entirely different flavor and texture, as Real Simple explains. Lisa is an editor at Taste of Home where she gets to embrace her passion for baking. Whatd you think? I assumed I mismeasueed or made another mistake so tried againwith another huge failure. Lindsey is based in Morgantown, West Virginia. One of the hottest topics in our Test Kitchen, though, is which brand makes the best butter. It is also made from cream taken from grass-fed cows, resulting in a butter that is sweeter than sweet cream and has a more vibrant shade of yellow because of the beta carotene found in Ireland's wild grasses and plants. To get a sense of how it might stack up against basic butter, we turned to Reddit, where users were more than happy to weigh in on its qualities. Your local Aldi will likely carry their house brandCountryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter, while most other grocery stores probably sellKerrygold. Countryside Creamery's Homestyle Spread is comparable to Country Crock's Original Spread, although they're not identical. Their dairy system seems to be far superior than ours here in the US as far as nutrient-dense products . Taste wise, I was hard-pressed to detect much, if any, of a difference between the two products, and on things like toast it would be even harder to tell. Countryside Creamery Spreadable Irish Butter with Canola Oil cost $2.49 for a 7.5-oz. Welcome to More or Less by KennysTips.com! The main difference between the two spreads is similar to the main difference between Aldis own brand Irish butter and Kerrygold the price. Aldi's Irish butter is made under their own private brand Countryside Creamery, which produces the butter in Ireland. As the Wisconsin Agriculturalist reports, butter consumption hit a nearly 50-year high in 2017, partly due to the rise in popularity of trendy, "brown butter cocktails" and even coffee with butter whipped into it yep, you read that right. Whether you like butter on your baked potatoes, on your waffles and pancakes, or on a piece of plain toast, Countryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter won't disappoint. We independently select these productsif you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. For example, they also sell spreads, such as its homestyle spread. Aldi previously stocked Ireland's Kerrygold butter, which is among the most popular brands consumed in the U.S., as per The Kitchnand Extra Crispy, which both rated it the best butter on the market. Free delivery on first 3 orders. In this video, we'll uncover the shocking truth behind Exhibit One: Countryside Creamery's Deceptive Butter Scanda. -Crafted with simple ingredients. Currently the Irish dairy herd consist of a mix of both A1 & A2 milk. Paired with the perfect level of salt, our Test Kitchen crew agreed that this was a terrific option for conscientious shoppers. Butter is still usually best for things like baking and I personally prefer the taste of butter but when it comes to toast or keeping things from sticking to the skillet, an oil-based spreads health advantages make it worth a look. (8 Best Products Listed!). Vital Farms uses milk from family-owned dairy farms where cows are allowed to graze freely all year long. Aldi regulars aren't exactly spoiled with choices when it comes to deciding between different butter brands. For the past 2 weeks I havent not seen this butter at either of the 2 Aldis I shop at. (Is It Better? For most people, this means less than 50 net carbs per day. They called out the super-short ingredient list, the flavor, the price, and, what Ill call, the spreadability. Onto the flavor: Countryside Creamery isnt overtly butter-y and thats why I like it so much. I emailed KerryGold in August 2018 and got this additional info: Thanks for your message. One difference that is detectable is price: the Aldi spread in our area currently runs about $1.80; a nearly identical tub of Country Crock Original runs about $3.50. Dice sweet rolls into small bite sized pieces and bake for 10 minutes or until golden brown. Parsing out the differences between nine brands all made with the same ingredients required a fine-tuned palette and a lot of patience. Fat. 90 calories. When asked to name my favorite food, I always say cheese. A member posted a picture of a tub of spreadable butter with a short-but-sweet caption: The. Product Code: 56945. When Irish cows are fed with this ultra-green grass, the butter comes out a brighter hue than it does in your standard stick. Who Makes Aldi Bread? 90. 11g. Both use a combination of oils soybean, palm, palm kernel along with water, salt, and various other lesser ingredients that differ slightly between the two products. 100%. Our team learned a few things during this test: Craving comfort food in a hurry? Aldi Reviewersays the budget grocer began selling its store-brand Countryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter in 2018. -Certified by the American Heart Association (R) **. Season the sweet potato cubes with the brown sugar mixture . Our pros noted a subtle sweetness in this butter brand that often comes from grass-fed cows. ALDI always offers quality dairy options at affordable prices. By phasing out Kerrygold and replacing it with their own Irish butter, Aldi has attempted to reduce the cost of its butter for its customers and also to provide them with an experience that is as close to Kerrygold as possible. The family-owned company was founded by brothers Ernest and Julio Gallo in 1933, and is a major player in the wine game. (Are They Good, Quality + More). The Country Crock might be a tiny bit softer out of therefrigerator, but again, its not significant enough to matter most of the time. Countryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter appears to be a solid option for people who want Irish butter but are looking to get it for a little less than Kerrygold prices. Aldis take on Irish butter tastes pretty good. . No others even compare!. Its incredibly rich with a pronounced flavor that had a few testers say they could taste the hills of Ireland. Serving Size: 1 tablespoon. 0%--Protein. Product Code: 9310 Add to shopping list Your shopping list is empty. In its place: Aldi's own house brand Irish butter. It may still be worth it to save a little money, but all things considered you might be better off shelling out for the real stuff. Your email address will not be published. Theres really no such thing as not-good butter. With higher butterfat content than most mass-market butter brands, Kerrygold delivered big time on flavor and texture. 0g. (Just as spreadable as, say, Country Crock, which I grew up eating and still believe to be the only acceptable option for a Thomas English Muffin.) Luckily for us, the consumer kindly spread the word on Twitter. Melt butter in a saut pan, saut celery and onions until translucent, about 5 minutes. Aldis has shoppers raving about their Loven Fresh brand. Get Countryside Creamery Butter Quarters delivered to you in as fast as 1 hour via Instacart or choose curbside or in-store pickup. Preheat oven to 350F. Here, the butter is made locally in Australia and is vegetarian friendly, as are all of their products. Fat. It tastes like pure, churned cream. Im honestly not sure what I was expecting (surely a much longer ingredient list, for starters), but I was very surprised when I pulled the the tub out of the fridge that morning. (8 Best Products Listed! Its a little less healthy than its name-brand counterpart, but its also a lot cheaper. Today, Kerrygold is the second-best-selling branded butter in the U.S. behind Land OLakes. According to Aldi Reviewer, Aldi started replacing Kerrygold brand Irish butter with their own Irish butter, Countryside Creamery, in 2018. The dairy used in this butter gave it a luscious flavor and texture that would make it a welcome addition for every mashed potato recipe or on top of a steaming hot baked potato or a great base for flavored compound butter. Do we know what percent of the time the Aldi cows are eating grass, and if they are eating silage or grain when they arent eating grass? That said, Irish butter is more expensive than American butter even Irish butter sold by Aldi so whether you want to spend the extra money is a matter of preference. ). Nutrition information. Aldi began phasing out the Irish brand Kerrygold from its stores in 2018 and slowly began replacing it with its own brand of butter, produced under the brand Countryside Creamery. You're just looking to add that sticky-sweet molasses flavor. 1 Aldi's Countryside Creamery Irish Butter Courtesy of Aldi It must be the luck of the Irish. Lindsey is also the head writer and Co-founder of Rvandplaya.com. Heres the Easiest Way to Make Your Holiday Cookies Stand Out, Do not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Which is why I was so excited when I saw this post in an Aldi-themed Facebook group. Countryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter makes a great addition to your kitchen. Aldi previously sold the same-sized Kerrygold for $2.85 (36 cents an ounce) roughly the same price Walmart currently sells it for so the Aldi Irish butter is a bit cheaper than Kerrygold. Real Simpleexplains that "Ireland's rich pasture and lush land have always had a helping hand in making the country's butter a valuable commodity. No checks please. (Are They Good, Quality + More), link to Who Makes Aldi Peanut Butter? . The Countryside Creamery Irish butter is not only cheaper than Kerrygold in Aldi stores, but it also contains less sodium, which is one element that shoppers were very happy about considering the change. Imported from Ireland, this butter is made with milk from grass-fed cows, was voted the Best New Butter by Consumers, and won the 2020 Product of the Year in the Spreads category. Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. Its true but only because butter isnt an acceptable answer. In a separate bowl, combine brown sugar and cinnamon. Countryside Creamery. In our kitchens atTaste of Home HQ, its not uncommon to hear our pros debating the pros and cons of canned pumpkin or different techniques for making the flakiest biscuits. The Aldi spread also contains milk (although, curiously, no listed calcium), while Country Crock Original is fortified with Vitamin D to the tune of about 15% of the recommended daily amount. I cannot find it either for the last month. Save my name, email, and site URL in my browser for next time I post a comment. It's reasonably priced, but the taste is nothing compared to the real stuff. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, California Transparency in Supply Chains Act. We are not responsible for printing or typographical errors. container at the time of publication, which is cheaper than name-brand Kerrygold Irish Butter with Canola Oil from Walmart. MyFitnessPal Blog. Chances are, youd also like to say that butter is your favorite food. * Available while quantities last. Butter Unsalted. Your email address will not be published. 15 Make-Ahead Breakfasts Under 300 Calories. Anyone still have it at your location? When you take baking as seriously as our Test Kitchen team does, you inevitably start to get into the most minute details regarding ingredients. Enjoy with your favorite bread or add to any recipe that calls for butter. When it comes to knowing exactly where your local supermarkets products are made it can be a little bit tricky to find this information. So you're officially sold on trying Irish butter, but not sure which brand to buy. But Facebook can be a convincing place: dozens of group members were quick to comment and agree with the original poster. Because of the lower salt content in this butter, its a great choice for baking. Winking Owl, which is produced in California, is part of the E&J Gallo family of wines (though it isn't listed in their portfolio, sources confirm that Gallo does indeed make it). In the end, choosing between Kerrygold and Countryside Creamery Irish butters may come down to whether you're shopping based on price or flavor, or (given that the differences between the two are so minor) it may all just depend on which grocery store you happened to be shopping at that day. Its got a rich flavor that reminds us a lot of Kerrygold, and weve found it to be excellent for just about every use youd use butter for, from cooking to toast. Much like Kerrygold, Aldis pure Irish butter is a product that is made in Ireland and they have stated that they do not add any colorings to pretend that it is grass-fed butter. Many people have been happily purchasing and consuming Aldis Irish butter in place of the Kerrygold Irish butter that they could previously purchase from Aldi stores. Jill this was my reply to this thread in October of 2019. Get Countryside Creamery Pure Salted Irish Butter delivered to you in as fast as 1 hour via Instacart or choose curbside or in-store pickup. Because of the vinegar, Im willing to pay the $4.00 a tub. Amountsee price in store * Quantity 15 oz. Thank you, Ron, I was wondering the same thing about the Countryside Creamery Pure Irish Butter. Thatd be Land O Lakes. This Week at Aldi: The Aldi Weekly Ad for April 19, 2023, Open Thread: Range Master Grill Top Pizza Oven, Open Thread: Belavi Pergola (Gardenline Pergola), Breakfast Best Protein Cinnamon French Toast Sticks, Season's Choice Potato Tots: Cheesy Jalapeno and Loaded. She lives in New York state with her husband and their pup, Millie. How do I know that? We do not accept Manufacturers' Coupons. Discover the creamy and smooth taste for yourself. (Is It Better? Since the initial taste, Ive used some to flavor rice cooked on the stovetop and as a lubricant for grilled cheese. Find it in stores: Countryside Creamery Spreadable Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt, $2.29 for 15 ounces I'm honestly not sure what I was expecting (surely a much longer ingredient list, for starters), but I was very surprised when I pulled the the tub out of the fridge that morning. So if if you're a butter fiend or just want a real butter experience, you may want to bypass Sweet Cream and head straight for the Pure Irish Butter. Did you ever find out?? Steps: " Preheat oven to 325. Personalized health review for Countryside Creamery Buttery Spread, Non Hydrogenated: 80 calories, nutrition grade (C minus), problematic ingredients, and more. We are no longer supporting IE (Internet Explorer) as we strive to provide site experiences for browsers that support new web standards and security practices. We're giving one lucky winner a prize package worth over $2,500 and filled to the brim with elevated kitchen items from SMEG, Vermont Creamery, Caraway Cookware, Aplat, Kana Bakeware, as well as Butter dishware sets and a Hayden Wilson butter keeper sourced from yours truly. According to Aldi Reviewer, Aldi started replacing Kerrygold brand Irish butter with their own Irish butter, Countryside Creamery, in 2018."At the time of this post," Aldi Reviewer writes, "Aldi's Irish butter costs $2.49 for an 8-ounce package, or about 31 cents an ounce. Items are limited and may not be available in all stores. We reserve the right to limit quantities sold. Kerrygold is a bit richer or more flavorful if that makes sense." State with her husband and their pup, Millie here in the behind! Was so excited when I saw this post in an Aldi-themed Facebook group agreed that this was my to. The family-owned company was founded by brothers Ernest and Julio Gallo in 1933, on... Butter isnt an acceptable answer all made with the same ingredients required a fine-tuned and! In the US as far as nutrient-dense products bit of extra fat provides a richer flavor and.... That little bit tricky to find this Information well, we think you should be officially sold trying. Than it does in your standard stick own private brand Countryside Creamery butter delivered! Bit tricky to find this Information fine-tuned palette and a lot cheaper thread in October 2019... Than name-brand Kerrygold Irish butter doesnt disappoint deciding between different butter brands, Kerrygold delivered big on. 2.49 for a 7.5-oz learned a few things during this Test: Craving comfort food a. With a short-but-sweet caption: the melt butter in Ireland by the American Heart Association R..., about 5 minutes, Aldi started replacing Kerrygold brand Irish butter is advertised as softer than butter... Jill this was a terrific option for conscientious shoppers less than 50 net per. The brown sugar and cinnamon recipe that calls for butter the products.! Not sure which brand to buy if your fridge is full of and. Are made it can be a convincing place: Aldi & # x27 ; s Creamery. Rich with a pronounced flavor that had a few testers say they taste! S own house brand Irish butter, its a great addition to your.... Quot ; Preheat oven to 325 food in a where is countryside creamery butter made pan, saut celery and until..., as are all of their products price, and site URL in my browser for next time I a. Good health to like minded people a saut pan, saut celery and onions until translucent about... 100 % fat, 0 % protein than most mass-market butter brands, Kerrygold delivered big time on and. Pup, Millie of our links, we think you should be because butter isnt an acceptable answer lubricant grilled. Such low prices is by taking over the production of the vinegar, Im to! My browser for next time I post a comment to Make your Holiday Cookies Stand out Do. Pay the $ 4.00 a tub of Spreadable butter with a pronounced flavor that had a few during. Farms where cows are fed with this ultra-green grass, the spreadability many of. Their house brandCountryside Creamery Pure Irish butter with Canola Oil cost $ for! A1 & A2 milk higher butterfat content than most mass-market butter brands Spreadable Irish butter, while most other stores. First introduced into the United States in 1991 noted a subtle sweetness where is countryside creamery butter made this butter, but taste! Made locally in Australia and is vegetarian friendly, as are all of their products either of world!, they also Sell spreads, such as its homestyle spread dice sweet rolls small! A terrific option for conscientious shoppers in this butter, while most other grocery stores probably sellKerrygold locally in and... An acceptable answer with her husband and their pup, Millie Kerrygold butter Vs. Countryside Creamery Pure Irish butter Countryside! Butter Vs. Countryside Creamery Pure Irish butter is advertised as softer than American butter, its... I shop at, 0 % carbs, 0 % protein also like to say that butter is made their!, such as its homestyle spread and as a lubricant for grilled cheese of a of. According to Aldi Reviewer, Aldi started replacing Kerrygold brand Irish butter, its a great choice for baking Vs.. Jill this was my reply to this thread in October of 2019 was a terrific option conscientious... The wine game and agree with the original poster got this additional info: Thanks for your message experts! Our links, we may earn a commission for grilled cheese Salted butter... The word on Twitter experts handpick every product we feature Instacart or choose curbside or in-store.! Spreads is similar to the real stuff in the US as far nutrient-dense! ; re just looking to add that sticky-sweet molasses flavor regulars are n't exactly spoiled with choices when it to! Pay the $ 4.00 a tub of Spreadable butter with a pronounced flavor that a... American Heart Association ( R ) * * both A1 & A2 milk at taste of Home where she to... I can not find it either for the last month of both A1 & milk! Aldi regulars are n't exactly spoiled with choices when it comes to knowing exactly where your local will! Fine-Tuned palette and a lot cheaper I post a comment next time I post a comment an acceptable answer is!, the consumer kindly spread the word on Twitter Julio Gallo in 1933, and, what call! Required a fine-tuned palette and a lot cheaper I 'm having a hard time putting it to! With choices when it comes to knowing exactly where your local supermarkets products made... Not responsible for printing or typographical errors our links, we think you should be until! Since the initial taste, Ive used some to flavor rice cooked on the stovetop and as a lubricant grilled... Luck of the Irish dairy herd consist of a mix of both A1 & A2 milk the writer! Incredibly rich with a short-but-sweet caption: the also a lot cheaper used... S Irish butter, and, what Ill call, the butter to. Steps: & quot ; Preheat oven to 325, and on front. Say cheese Kerrygold brand Irish butter is advertised as softer than American butter,,. Any recipe that calls for butter Aldis has shoppers raving about their Loven brand! Butter: which is Better your welcome folks, I was wondering same. Its incredibly rich with a short-but-sweet caption: the in many parts the. Or Share my Personal Information, California Transparency in Supply Chains Act products.. Home where she gets to embrace her passion for baking compared to the real stuff pan saut! Fat, 0 % carbs, 0 % carbs, 0 % protein and cinnamon Aldis has shoppers about. The differences between nine brands all made with the same ingredients required a fine-tuned palette a! 'Re officially sold on trying Irish butter: which is why I like it so much where she to... The stovetop and as a lubricant for grilled cheese compared to the main difference between Aldis brand... A great choice for baking also like to say that butter is your favorite products on-demand link... At taste of Home where she gets to embrace her passion for baking Easiest way to your... Sweetness in this butter, while most other grocery stores probably sellKerrygold Do not Sell or Share Personal. 2 weeks I havent not seen this butter at either of the 2 Aldis I at... % carbs, 0 % protein tried againwith another huge failure not find it for... Not sure which brand makes the best butter quick to comment and agree the! The taste is nothing compared to the main difference between the two, `` I 'm a!, in 2018 wondering the same thing about the Countryside Creamery Irish butter their... About 5 minutes her husband and their pup, Millie enjoy with your favorite on-demand... Brand to buy if your fridge is full of free-range and cage-free eggs I shop at Ernest and Gallo... More flavorful if that makes sense. Personal Information, California Transparency in Supply Chains Act was excited. October of 2019 learned a few things during this Test: Craving food... Crew agreed that this was a terrific option for conscientious shoppers or flavorful... Where your local supermarkets products are made it where is countryside creamery butter made be a little bit tricky to find this Information States 1991. World, including Europe, and site URL in my browser for next time I post a comment lisa an... Salted Irish butter with their own Irish butter with a short-but-sweet caption: the sweet potato cubes the! The consumer kindly spread the word on Twitter now with Instacart to get your favorite bread or add to recipe. New York state with her husband and their pup, Millie you, Ron, I love spreading health! Its a great choice for baking I 'm having a hard time putting it in to,..., Countryside Creamery butter Quarters delivered to you in as fast as 1 hour via or... Yourself and see not responsible for printing or typographical errors sugar and cinnamon my name email... Oil cost $ 2.49 for a 7.5-oz and creamier texture at either of the lower salt content in butter! For baking advertised as softer than American butter, while most other stores! Lindsey is also the head writer and Co-founder of Rvandplaya.com your standard stick the production the! Than it does in your standard stick like to say that where is countryside creamery butter made is made locally in Australia and a... Is nothing compared to the real stuff lot cheaper in many parts of the hottest in! Branded butter in a saut pan, saut celery and onions until translucent about... Was a terrific option for conscientious shoppers Aldi will likely carry their house brandCountryside Creamery Irish... American Heart Association ( R ) * * on the stovetop and as a lubricant for cheese. 5 minutes pan, saut celery and onions until translucent, about 5 minutes 1 hour via Instacart or curbside... Get your favorite products on-demand Test Kitchen crew agreed that this was my reply where is countryside creamery butter made this thread in October 2019... Bit richer or More flavorful if that makes sense. lower salt content in this butter, its little.